Arama They Didn't

12:16 am - 04/28/2012

No Nyan after 8 pm?



Tokyo cat cafes' night hours to be no meow


Evening exploitation rubbing animal rights groups wrong way


By KYOKO HASEGAWA
AFP-Jiji

For young females looking to while away an evening with a cappuccino and a flock of felines, Tokyo's "neko cafes" are an oasis that allow their clientele to unwind and soothe their stress.

"After a long day's work, all I want to do is to pet cats and relax," said Akiko Harada, a saleswoman and regular customer at such establishments. "I love cats, but I can't keep one at home because I live in a small apartment. I started going (to cat cafes) because I really missed stroking and having fun with cats."

For Harada and others who share her predilection, Tokyo's neko cafes, and the cats in them, offer customers a temporary release from daily pressures — although they charge a premium for the coffee served.

Animal rights campaigners, however, have started targeting the establishments for allegedly exploiting — and profiting from — the animals, which activists also claim are subjected to extreme stress in their unnatural habitat.

Cat cafe foes have welcomed a new ordinance that will ban them from displaying the animals in public after 8 p.m. The law will enter into force later this year.

The measure was drawn up by the Environment Ministry, after it received more than 155,000 requests from concerned citizens demanding it end the "exploitative" practices of cat cafes — an unusually strong response given the public's frequent ambivalence on such issues.



The law primarily targets businesses in Tokyo's entertainment districts that display pets in cramped glass tanks, including cats and dogs, until late at night in dazzlingly bright shop fronts, a sales ploy that regularly raises eyebrows among Western visitors.

But Shinji Yoshida, who manages a neko cafe in the capital, said the new regulation would also apply to his business, which will be forced to close earlier in the evening, his busiest time, and hurt his bottom line.

According to Yoshida, about 80 percent of his customers are salaried employees who drop by to relax after their daily grind before their long commutes home.

"If I have to close my cafe at 8 p.m., I'll go into the red," said Yoshida, 32. "It is a huge blow to cat cafes, and the new law has nothing to do with protecting the animals' health."

Yoshida said the 13 cats at his establishment in Ikebukuro, a teeming commercial and commuter hub, are free to roam and jump around to their heart's content, adding they can also clamber all over a large artificial tree.

"As you can see, the cats are free to happily walk around and play. I also ask customers not to disturb the cats if they are sleeping, and at night we dim the lights," he said. "And cats can also rest during the day."

His patrons also hit the new law.

Ayako Kanzaki, a 22-year-old office worker, said she began visiting cat cafes three years ago because she loves the animals and her apartment is too small to keep a pet of her own.

"I like to do things at my own pace, and I must say that I am not a very social person. So I come here alone, because I want to focus on the cats," she said.

"During the day, the cats are mostly sleeping, and even if they are awake, they often don't pay any attention to the customers. But in the evening they are very lively, and it's more enjoyable."

Harada, the saleswoman, feels equally strongly. "If cat cafes are shut down at night, I won't have many opportunities to visit them any more," she said.

But animal welfare activists continue to push the government to act against such businesses, which one, Chizuko Yamaguchi, accused of stressing out the cats due to the sheer number of customers seeking their attention.

"From morning till night, these cats are being stroked by strangers," Yamaguchi said. "For the animals, that is a real source of stress."

But Fusako Nogami, who heads the ALIVE animal rights group and who acknowledged the new law is a positive step, said cat cafes in themselves are not the real problem.

The commodification of animals, which often results in pets being viewed merely as fashion accessories rather than animals that require special care and treatment, is the fundamental issue the public and government must address, Nogami said.

"What deserves more public attention is the way pets are currently sold in Japan," she said. "We need to ban trade in newborn kittens and puppies, which businesses profit from because they are considered cute and sell well."




Source
I disagree with the Yamaguchi's statement (which is accusing that cat cafes are mistreating the animals). As a cat-person, who also can't keep a cat at home, cat cafes is the best solution. And they treat the cats well. They're nocturnal creature anyway. They party at night, mind you >.>
Though I agree with Nogami's statement. Pet shouldn't be fashion accessories. They should be our life-long companion :3

mrs_koki 27th-Apr-2012 07:19 pm (UTC)
Wouldn't that be the same thing as kittens for sale in a pet shop window? I mean the kittens are on display and for sale in pet shops and yet that's okay. The cats in these cafes are well taken care of and they wouldn't be popular if the owners were mistreating the animals and they were in poor condition.


While I do believe cats themselves aren't fashion accessories as well, but these groups need find something more constructive to do. I have three cats in my home and my cat would love to be an accessory if I'd let her out of the house without a harness and leash.
abusedpancake 27th-Apr-2012 10:51 pm (UTC)
the first part of your comment confused me.. the article said that the pets sold in japan are exposed to strong lights in the night, and hell do i know cats dont like strong lights at that time..mine dont... plus the cats and puppies they sell are about 1 week old, because thats when they're the cutest. japanese are crazy for cute stuff. and we all know its not even good for pets that young to be taken away from their mothers...

i dont mean to patronize you, it just seemed you didnt understand the article..
yaoilicious_53 27th-Apr-2012 07:20 pm (UTC)
This reminds me.. I'M BUYING A NEW CAT THIS SUMMER <3
Currently, I have one cat... I've been raising cats since I was 5. In total, I have raised 46 cats 8D
neen_chan 27th-Apr-2012 09:15 pm (UTC)
Cat Lady.

Foreveralone.jpg
cruel_idol 27th-Apr-2012 07:21 pm (UTC)
Can't have cats (allergic) but it's cool there are places people can go to enjoy them.

Lol at the gif!
brucelynn 27th-Apr-2012 07:59 pm (UTC)
....I love cats ^___^ I have a beautiful tuxedo cat at home and I love her
hisjulliet 27th-Apr-2012 08:00 pm (UTC)
Does anybody on here know if Japan has more people that own cats more than dogs?
wayof_life 27th-Apr-2012 08:11 pm (UTC)
Dogs more than cats, by quite a fair bit too. But the data varies from date to date, and they are not super duper recent data...

Sources:
http://lovemeow.com/2010/03/japans-love-for-cats-and-dogs/
http://whatjapanthinks.com/2009/07/02/dogs-cats-and-goldfish-most-popular-pets-in-japan/#more-2195
http://www.zenoaq.jp/english/aij/0201.html
thefortysecond 27th-Apr-2012 08:05 pm (UTC)
I dunno, I disagree with the idea that those cats are there only to be accessories. Personally? I'd love to have a companion cat of my own, but I'm not in a financial or logistical position to provide the level of care I want to give. I try to make visits to volunteer at animal shelters, but I would love to visit a cafe like this too. Not to be fashionable, just because I love cats.

From the sound of it, most of the people who patronize these kinds of cafes genuinely love the animals, and aren't using them as a status object. If the cats were in ill health or temperamental from poor treatment, I have a feeling the cafes wouldn't be doing nearly as well either. It's good business to keep the cats happy. Sure, maybe a few cafes here or there are abusive to them, but the new laws should be focusing on cracking down on those, instead of making a blanket rule that affects places that aren't doing anything wrong.

(oh man i sound like a crazy cat lady in this comment don't i?)
katzsong 28th-Apr-2012 03:08 am (UTC)
As I've said above, we love cat ladies ^^ nyan ~
wayof_life 27th-Apr-2012 08:18 pm (UTC)
IDK, I don't think the cats in these cat cafes are being treated as accessories whatsoever? I think they're pretty loved, more than those in cases/plastic boxes in pet shops ._. The animals in pet shops are pretty sad, like those I've seen in Tokyo, some pet shops are so small, they can't afford having many of them out and walking, so they're stuck in the cages/boxes, and those cages/boxes are really small, due to the size of the shop. They don't get much movement and interaction with people. The cats in the cat cafes get affection from customers, and the staff treat them rather well (at least in Japan; can't guarantee those in Taiwan). The cats are free to roam around and interact if they want, there isn't much restriction. The only thing that is down for cat cafes is these cats don't have an actual owner.

And if they're going to shut these cafes at such an early time, the people who will benefit from it are tourists, students, NEETs, retirees and people along that line. Working adults most likely won't get to go, at least on weekdays, because when work ends, it's already past 9pm >_>
katzsong 28th-Apr-2012 01:55 am (UTC)
The animals in pet shops are pretty sad, like those I've seen in Tokyo, some pet shops are so small, they can't afford having many of them out and walking, so they're stuck in the cages/boxes, and those cages/boxes are really small, due to the size of the shop. They don't get much movement and interaction with people.

That what I suspect. I think those complaints should be addressed to those kind of pet shops, not cat cafes (though there might be some bad cat cafes).
Idk, I've been watching much TV programs about cats lately (Must love cats, Too cute, the Science of cats), and one of it even has a report from the cat cafes in Japan. And the cafes are lovely, the cats are well treated and love the affections from the visitors. Most cafes have clear rules that visitors should respect the cat and let them choose the humans, not the other way around.



benihime99 27th-Apr-2012 08:23 pm (UTC)
They party at night, mind you >.>

Don't know my cat spend all night sleeping on my belly tbh



Edited at 2012-04-27 08:24 pm (UTC)
abusedpancake 27th-Apr-2012 10:54 pm (UTC)
my cats both party and sleep at night.. it depends on their mood, lol
ringoroll 27th-Apr-2012 08:24 pm (UTC)
Won't you pleeeease think of the children cats? D8

Newsflash; there are cats who love attention and are not bothered if they are being stroked. Well okay, if there are many people stroking I can understand why they would feel uneasy. How many customers per one cat are there usually in a cat cafe?

Seriously though, if the owners really threat the cats as they are telling, I have a hard time believing the cats are stressed (or that the customers who visit the cafes think of cats as objects).

Edited at 2012-04-27 08:25 pm (UTC)
wayof_life 28th-Apr-2012 02:45 am (UTC)
In Japan, most of the cafes don't have restriction like one person to one cat, but they have a cap on how many customers can be in the cafe within the time slot (which is somewhat like one person to one cat, but not that strictly). That's why a lot of cafes encourage customers to make reservations to avoid being disappointed~
pabu 27th-Apr-2012 08:25 pm (UTC)
I don't know what to think about this. I mean, every video and every picture I've seen of the cat cafes, the cats seemed to be allowed to roam around. Maybe there's like really seedy ones that do that?
aquariia 27th-Apr-2012 08:56 pm (UTC)
So after 8 p.m those cats will be locked in small rooms/apartments.
People from Environment Ministry apearentlly never had a cat.
I have 3 cats, all of them don't like staying alone and seek for attention.
Overreacting so much.


elizajet 27th-Apr-2012 09:17 pm (UTC)
That's dumb.

Cats are mostly nocturnal, and the times that the Japanese can go see them and give them attention are after work- so wouldn't it make more sense to have them not work during the day?
ookameoo 27th-Apr-2012 09:49 pm (UTC)
"They party at night, mind you >.>"



katzsong 28th-Apr-2012 01:57 am (UTC)
LMAO I like it when the cat throws his paws in the air. But when his paw on the disc, looks like it gonna kill someone XD
bleu_skies 27th-Apr-2012 10:16 pm (UTC)
As long as the cats are being treated well and with respect, I don't see why the law should apply to the cafe tbh.
uledy 27th-Apr-2012 10:37 pm (UTC)
Oh, well...I'm against the domestication of animals so any concept of fashion accessories or life-long companionship with animals is no go with me. But since that's not realistic, I hope they treat the animals well and give them lots of love <3

Anyway, just here for the adorable title :3
katzsong 28th-Apr-2012 02:07 am (UTC)
well, most cats that we know now is a domesticated breed already (domestic house cats/mixbreed). More than 90% I believe. There are wild cats breed like serval or savannah, etc. Those wild cat are better of to live in the wild.
Domestic cats is okay to be...well, domesticated or live in a house. They do still have their natural hunter's instinct, so their living space must accommodate their needs for active nature (climbs up, scratch post, well-maintained litter box, etc). Most cat cafes (that I've seen on the net or TV programs) have that and they treat the cats well. That's why I disagree with some of the statement in the article.
scorchy96 27th-Apr-2012 10:50 pm (UTC)
The only cat cafe I went to, all the cats seemed to have some sort of kennel illness and were irritable from all the people coming in, so, have to say I'm not against this law.
exdream1999 27th-Apr-2012 11:00 pm (UTC)
I get where you're coming from, at least with the amount of people.

I've been to cafes at times when it was busy and then when it wasn't so much so, and the difference was amazing.

I'd rather there be a max limit on customers.
taciturndream 27th-Apr-2012 11:02 pm (UTC)
I don't have a solid opinion, I guess some cats are sociable and like attention all the time, and these must be trained since kittens for this. But, stress doesn't mean bad treatment people...animals can get stressed by being touched all the time and stuff. I SUPPOSE the activists might have studied the case before going against it.

Yet I think it's silly, they should stop the cats working hours to the day so they can rest, and not the night.
soundczech 28th-Apr-2012 01:51 am (UTC)
I don't know enough about cat cafes to have an opinion about them, but WORD about the newborn kittens, i'm horrified by the size of some of the kittens i see for sale here. they're so cute but WAY TOO YOUNG TO BE AWAY FROM THEIR MOTHERS D: D: D: D: D: D: D:
katzsong 28th-Apr-2012 02:20 am (UTC)
yeah, that's terrible. cats must be at least 10 weeks old to be separated from their parents. Heck, even a full grown cat is still cute for me :)
haimazn 28th-Apr-2012 04:33 am (UTC)
catcafes4life tbh. I've been to one a couple times and for me personally, it didn't seem like they were treating the cats awfully~ The environment was nice but then again the one I go to is pretty nice (tho my friends have said similar things at different cat/dog cafes).

plus my bf finds it necessary as it deters me from trying to pet stray cats because I miss my kitty

westerners should look at their own animal establishments before judging japan's cat/dog cafes.

Edited at 2012-04-28 04:33 am (UTC)
fumine 29th-Apr-2012 12:13 am (UTC)
"westerners should look at their own animal establishments before judging japan's cat/dog cafes."

May I just ask where did the Westerners come from now? O_o
Because this article was about Japanese citizens complaining about cat cafes.

Still judging Japan on animal welfare, although cat cafes are far from being the main problem there...
benihime99 OT but not so much and it's so cute I can't resist28th-Apr-2012 08:16 am (UTC)
Old vid but I love it
katzsong Re: OT but not so much and it's so cute I can't resist28th-Apr-2012 01:53 pm (UTC)
Oh this, the old "surprised cat" XDD she's such a cutie <33333
mjspice 28th-Apr-2012 10:10 am (UTC)
Thought they had dealt with this issue...oh well.

That aside, I just love cats. :)
fumine 28th-Apr-2012 11:51 pm (UTC)
"What deserves more public attention is the way pets are currently sold in Japan," she said. "We need to ban trade in newborn kittens and puppies, which businesses profit from because they are considered cute and sell well."

This is the most sensible line in the whole article IMO
The rest sounds kind of half-assed at times.

I don't think neko cafes are the biggest problem, though there are points that make me worry.
"I also ask customers not to disturb the cats if they are sleeping"
I think there will be customers who have an interest in cuddling the cat no matter when; after all, they are paying for it. As a shop owner, what can you really do about that? If you speak against a customer and don't let them have their will, it is likely that they won't come back. That's just bad for business.
I also don't think a place to rest is enough for most cats when they are still being on display. Cats also need hiding places where they can retreat to.

"will ban them from displaying the animals in public after 8 p.m."
Just from displaying? There's nothing changing about the way they are being held or bred (kitten/puppy mills)?
This page was loaded May 19th 2013, 1:15 pm GMT.