Arama They Didn't

4:28 pm - 05/02/2012

TBS treats its extras like slaves





 

Wanna be on TV? Even if you think you do, you don’t – at least not as an extra at TV network TBS, if FRIDAY (May 11-18) is to be believed.

“Slavery,” “labor camp” – you don’t expect a TV studio to evoke such images. Well, judge for yourself. Here were 160 extras crammed into a roughly 20-mat room, waiting to be brought before the cameras. Leaving the room was forbidden. There was a convenience store in the building, but as the hours dragged on and people started getting hungry, it was declared off limits by sharp-eyed, sharp-tongued TBS staffers. Also off limits were the staff elevators.


When their turn came, the extras had to take the stairs from the third floor to the studio on the 11th – several times in the course of the day. How long a day? Nearly 12 hours, as it turned out. The pay was 2,500 yen, which works out to about 200 yen an hour.

Tempers flared, naturally. The harassed extras turned on each other, pushing and shoving for a bit of space. Some, feeling ill, made up their minds to forego the pay and leave. Nothing doing. “That’s contract violation – we won’t let you go!” shouted one of the ever-vigilant staffers.



What program was being filmed? It was the variety show “Job Tune,” emceed by the comedy trio Neptune, and the irony is that the show’s theme is the seamy side of various kinds of employment, the guests being people who have been through the mill and know whereof they speak. Friday’s allegations, backed by comments from the extras themselves (who, however, are unnamed), pertain to the April 16 taping of the program aired on April 26.

At one point, a “floor director” attempted to rally people’s spirits. “Listen,” he said, “applaud and react as vigorously as you can. If you do, our ratings will go up and you’ll get regular spots on the program.” This exhortation, we are told, was received without much interest.

When, around 11 p.m., the ordeal was finally over, the extras were reportedly told, “You are absolutely not to reveal anything you saw or heard today on the Internet. We have your individual information. If any information goes out on the Net, we’ll go after the criminal and make him or her take responsibility!”

Contacted by Friday, TBS seemed puzzled as to what the fuss was about. “We informed the extras beforehand about the pay, the hours they’d be needed, the meal situation and so on, and they were enlisted after their approval was obtained,” a network spokesperson said. “There was no trouble of the sort you speak of.”

So it boils down to who you choose to believe. Being an extra used to be a pretty good deal, FRIDAY says – with pay averaging 5,000 yen to 10,000 yen a day. Then the recession set in, and the good old days became a fading memory – in the TV field as in so many others.





japantoday
squallina 3rd-May-2012 01:04 am (UTC)
Are we talking audience extras, as in just the people in the studio audience? Since when are studio audiences paid?

Don't know much about all TV extras, but where Arashi shows are concerned I'm pretty sure studio audiences on their shows actually pay to be there (because you have to be a FC member) and they're told not to say anything about the show online etc. The ones who are extras in drama series are volunteers too, also usually gathered from the fan club. Not that I've ever been, but this is what I've heard from friends and read in my own fanclub mail.

If they knew about the meals in advance, fair enough, bring your own. If they didn't know about the meals thing, shame on you TBS. The room thing is a bit much too. Even if people are banned from leaving, should be a bigger room for that number. :(
hpswf1 3rd-May-2012 02:37 am (UTC)
About dramas is not always via FC, tvchannel sometimes make announce on their sites for it, like it was with Ataru
squallina 3rd-May-2012 02:59 am (UTC)
IC. Thanks for the correction. :)
ohprecioustime 3rd-May-2012 01:05 am (UTC)
2.50 an hour!!!

I totally believe the extras, it so easy to abuse people who want a job especially in tough times
mellastella 3rd-May-2012 01:22 am (UTC)
I'm not exactly sure what to make of this. :(
crumplelush 3rd-May-2012 01:27 am (UTC)
Some, feeling ill, made up their minds to forego the pay and leave. Nothing doing. “That’s contract violation – we won’t let you go!” shouted one of the ever-vigilant staffers.

This would be the point I called the police and informed then I was being held against my will. Just start that conversation and I bet they'll let you go asap.
chokingday 3rd-May-2012 04:44 am (UTC)
I've heard of similar things happening to the Chinese staff here (Mainland), so I can easily believe this part, tbh.
chibi_hime 3rd-May-2012 02:20 am (UTC)
I was an extra for Buzzer Beat (Fuji TV?) and several movies. Even when they didn't pay me, they fed me and it was an interesting experience.

So if TBS is really treating people like that, shame on them.
squallina 3rd-May-2012 03:00 am (UTC)
+1
jeugd1 3rd-May-2012 05:54 am (UTC)
I was an extra for Buzzer Beat
Did you get to talk to Yamapi?

Edited at 2012-05-03 07:45 am (UTC)
december_clouds 3rd-May-2012 08:37 am (UTC)
How did you get to do that? That sounds interesting.
tamaoadams 3rd-May-2012 03:16 am (UTC)
At least they got paid. Im saying this cause I know extras that get worst than this and they are not paid. =(
annhh 3rd-May-2012 10:31 am (UTC)
This is just too much. They're treating real people like rats. And even threats.. That's like abusive husband. I'd report.

I was offered to be an extra and I'm flattered but it didn't pay so I didn't go. It basically wasn't interesting enough to do the trouble
mjspice 3rd-May-2012 11:49 am (UTC)
Damn.....
dramaticsurgeon 3rd-May-2012 12:37 pm (UTC)
Honestly I'm not too sure about policies regarding extras in Japan, but that story's not too unbelievable. In America there are often agencies you sign up with and you get sent on various shows, where you either get paid a stipend or are fed for the time you're there. Some folks even make a living for themselves this way, although the pay's not necessarily consistent. The lucky extras manage to snag a voucher that gets them one step closer to joining the actors' union.

Then again, I've heard equally horrible tales of mistreatment and borderline harassment. I suppose that can happen anywhere, really. Usually if both sides are saying outlandishly different things ("They treated us like dogs"/"No, nothing happened at all"), the truth lies somewhere in between. Maybe the extras wrangler or backstage coordinator got a little too big for themselves that day or took their frustration out on the extras.

I doubt TBS itself would condone these actions since every show needs extras. If the extras on this show were treated poorly and neglected, there's no way that wouldn't get out, and TBS would suddenly find fewer people signing up.
hyxmk 4th-May-2012 07:46 am (UTC)
ANd thats why NTV IS DA BEST
crystalluvshun 4th-May-2012 05:44 pm (UTC)
+1

for me, NTV is the best for several reasons.

Edited at 2012-05-04 05:45 pm (UTC)
nakabibighani 5th-May-2012 12:07 am (UTC)
So sad to hear. In each industry, there are people who are taken advantage of...
This page was loaded May 25th 2013, 4:20 am GMT.