Arama They Didn't

2:03 pm - 05/10/2012

K-Pop star bashed in Korea after wearing Japan T-Shirt



On the 2nd, K-Pop star Hyeri of the Korean idol group Girl’s Day apologized after she received criticism from Korean fans for wearing a T-Shirt embroiled with the Japanese naval flag.

Hyeri apologized formally through her agency, “I bow my head and apologize for not being more cautious.”

“Because I caused a lot of trouble to many people I am truly sorry, and I will be careful to make sure this won’t happen again.”

Hyeri continued, “When I saw the shirt I was only thinking of the message of helping Japan, I didn’t pay attention to the print. Whatever I say it’s a mistake that I can’t excuse.”

Hyeri received shirts from Japanese fans at certain event rehearsals and wore these shirts onto the stage, where she was taped by fans who published these pictures onto the internet.

In Korea, the Japanese naval flag symbolizes Japanese militarism and the Japanese occupation of Korea. K-Pop stars active in Japan must take precaution when it comes to topics on Japan related topics and words, as it is easy to take criticism from their home country.

Korean media called out Hyeri for the print of the clothing. The Dong-a Illbo, a Korean newspaper, criticized Hyeri, “Recklessly wearing clothes from fans is dangerous.”

Hankook Ilbo, another Korean newspaper, also had words for Hyeri after specifying the flag’s connotations with Japanese militarism, “In this case, ‘I didn’t know’ won’t work at all.” They also stressed K-Pop stars who are active in other countries should practice their love for Korea.

Girl’s Day, who debuted in 2010, is currently active in Japan, holding solo concerts on the 2nd and the 6th.

Source: urageispo.com, translated by: omoxi
Page 1 of 3
<<[1] [2] [3] >>
chesutoberry 10th-May-2012 07:28 am (UTC)


squallina 10th-May-2012 08:19 am (UTC)
lol at the collective facepalm! xD
shikinluv 10th-May-2012 07:29 am (UTC)
If they only took notice of what the shirt actually said...

While I understand why it's offensive, that shit they're writing is just pure nationalistic bull. I'm more offended that they think it's okay to influence youths to hate.
antifools 10th-May-2012 11:41 am (UTC)
That's what the Koreans teach their children. Hatred for the Japanese.
redgreendress 10th-May-2012 07:34 am (UTC)
I was reading about this flag just now. I never even knew until recently that it was such a big deal.

Well, Japan should've probably changed the flag once the war ended. Apparently there's a different version for the self-defense force, but it's not as commonly used, which is a shame. I understand the sensitivity, but the shirt was a Help Japan t-shirt, not a I Support Japanese Militarism t-shirt. A bit of an overreaction, I think, especially since the girl did the only thing anybody can do in this situation, which is saying "my bad, won't happen again" and moving on with your life.

Edited at 2012-05-10 01:08 pm (UTC)
mikan_daisuki 10th-May-2012 07:35 am (UTC)
Give the girl a break, Korea... (^^;;)
I understand where all the criticism is coming from, but it's not like a girl this young has ever experienced what Japanese militarism was like and would be able to automatically associate the flag with negative connotations... I just hope that differences can be put aside as the younger generations in Japan and Korea work towards better cooperation.

I dunno, I guess I'm just coming from the perspective of "the past can't be changed, but let's work towards a better future." Since we're all stuck with each other anyway. lol.
hisjulliet 10th-May-2012 07:40 am (UTC)
Great comment. You said everything I wanted to say about this issue
ocha_suki 10th-May-2012 07:36 am (UTC)
it's funny how they starve for Japan Yen but hate the print of Japan flag on the t-shirt just bcoz! *shrug*
labeledlikeme 10th-May-2012 07:43 am (UTC)
THIS.
yasmine2009 10th-May-2012 07:37 am (UTC)
Wow. I know that flag represents something that is a sensitive subject to SK, but the girl was trying to do something positive. Sit down. It's not like she went on an anti- Korea campaign. Innocent mistake.
zaziemuto 10th-May-2012 07:39 am (UTC)
Ehm. Why making such a big deal out of it? Thats what I call over acting... Really, no further comment needed. Said everything.
midwinter_taion 10th-May-2012 08:06 am (UTC)
Would you wear a shirt with a Nazi symbol in Europe?
This is the same.
tensaibaka 10th-May-2012 07:39 am (UTC)
you poor thing.
hazel_darlene 10th-May-2012 07:57 am (UTC)

they're making too much fuss abt the design >__<
korean media really >__<

that's why I dislike them

Edited at 2012-05-10 08:00 am (UTC)
princessayra 10th-May-2012 07:58 am (UTC)
"They also stressed K-Pop stars who are active in other countries should practice their love for Korea."

Oh, here's a great way to show your love:

STAY IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY.
e_namor 10th-May-2012 08:11 am (UTC)
THIS. SO MUCH.
sashwizzled 10th-May-2012 08:03 am (UTC)
It was a silly mistake and one she doesn't deserve to spend the rest of the year being dragged through the mud over like she probably will be.

THAT SAID, that flag represents multiple decades of Korea being occupied by Japan, Koreans being tortured, sexually abused, killed in the dozens and hundreds for shits and giggles, experimented upon and forced to give up their language and national identity because Japan wanted an ~empire~. Then Japan spending decades and decades after that not even admitting they did any of that shit and Korea having to wring every last fauxpology out of them.

Koreans have a pretty damn good reason to hate that flag and what it represents.

hth
harisukaori 10th-May-2012 10:48 am (UTC)
Thank you for a sensible comment :)
yuma_daisuki 10th-May-2012 08:16 am (UTC)
Big deal huh~~~ -.-
squallina 10th-May-2012 08:29 am (UTC)
Well, if it bothers you that much, Korea, you can have all your K-pop groups here in Japan who trying to keep you in business the hell back. Open your big mouths and whine when you don't need the income these hard workers are bringing you to keep your music scene alive. I understand there's a history of bad blood to be taken into an account, but to indirectly treat the people who are keeping K-pop financially valid like this is anything but classy. >:(
quietspeaker2 10th-May-2012 08:40 am (UTC)
this!you said what I wanted to say.
chibi_rei 10th-May-2012 08:43 am (UTC)
You want other countries to love your stars, you want them to be successful, et cetra, but then something as small as a shirt gets them riled up. I understand the history and the tense feeling between the countries... but it seems like dwelling on such things just impedes any chance of being able to move forward.
queencrystallia 10th-May-2012 07:24 pm (UTC)
YOU SAID IT ALL
it is dumb.
Korea will never move on though. they learn how to hate :|
convenience93 10th-May-2012 09:08 am (UTC)
Awws I pity the girl.
mjspice 10th-May-2012 09:58 am (UTC)
So much fail in this article. I can't even...
tapsilogue 10th-May-2012 10:01 am (UTC)
Some comments here make sense, but WOW the amount of ignorance. And to all the people who belittle whatever suffering Korea had to go through as a nation under Japan: shame on you.

My country (I come from the Philippines) was also occupied by Japan in what were some of the bloodiest days in our history, but we don't really react violently to anything Japanese (we welcome their technology and anime and even recently had a JPop fest and in fact many of our roads and tunnels are Japan-made, including an airport), so I do understand where you're all coming from with the "it's all in the past" argument. My grandma, who lived through the war, doesn't understand how so many people could like Japan or why I would want to study there in the future because she sees Japan very differently from how I do. So I know where you guys are coming from. But Korea is different from you me - Korean citizens (in particular, the ones being talked about in the article) are different from you and me. And I don't think it's our business to tell them what they should or should not be feeling. :/

Now I'm not saying that we should always focus on what happened in the past or that we shouldn't move on, all I'm saying is that they didn't react this way just because Japan was included in the situation or just because it was in the girl's shirt design (that would be a different discussion altogether, with different variables in the equation); they reacted that violently because it was Japan's military flag. Some Jews are still offended by the Nazi symbol - and who can blame them? Still, some have "moved on," and that's their choice. No one's in the right or wrong - and we have no right to tell them whether they're right or wrong - simply because past events affect different people in different ways. "But what Japan did to Korea is less violent" you say - but victims don't think about their suffering in relation to other people's. They were victimized, and it definitely shaped how they are now as a nation. I think it's unfair of us to be treating them as if what happened to them - no matter how far back it was - should be forgiven and forgotten when clearly, they are not ready to do that as a nation. In particular, it's annoying to read "God move ON Korea!" comments because who the hell are you to tell them what they should or should not do?

I'm not saying Koreans hating on a Japanese person or on Japanese people is justified. I don't agree that people should hate others purely because of their heritage or citizenship. I'm saying these people have a right to be offended by a symbol which reminds them of whatever they had to suffer through before.

And about them earning money by sending their talent to Japan - that doesn't mean they love their country any less. Again, coming from a country with a really high number of overseas workers (almost 10M accdg to a gov't website), remittances really help the country's economy. Remittances in USD in 2005 alone contributed US$10 Billion to the Philippine economy.

tl;dr: I'm not a fan of K-Pop (it's not my cup of tea tbh) or Korea in general, but IDK. It's just unfair to be calling them out for being offended over something we have no first hand experience of (and by first hand, I mean of being a Korean or living there). I also think too much nationalism is bad and I frown upon nationalism to the point that you marginalize people just because of their citizenship, but in this case, it's unfair for us to be calling them out because they were offended over something they had every right to be offended about.
janri 10th-May-2012 10:24 am (UTC)
Sad this comment didn't get any replies to it. I 100% agree with you.
pabu 10th-May-2012 10:07 am (UTC)
I'm side eyeing half of the comments in this post.
sundaetea 11th-May-2012 06:30 am (UTC)
MTE! I was like, "So this is how people really feel..."
citrus_lime 10th-May-2012 10:09 am (UTC)
I know I don't have first hand experience with the war, but I also can't help feeling like

mrstaguchi100 10th-May-2012 10:11 am (UTC)
as stated by the great Matsuko Deluxe:

GTFO is you hate japan that much.

Poor girl was probably trying to be a nice person and the korean media just went apeshit over nothing. This is why i really can't stand people like this... they think they're so much better than everyone else, that the world owes them everything and that the victim game is fun to play. hello? people get sick of crap, generally = ='
harisukaori 10th-May-2012 11:06 am (UTC)
Are you serious with your comment? You really think this is nothing?! This flag symbolizes years of occupation and torture to the Korean people so how can you say that it's nothing?! Moreover it's a symbol of war crimes that have never been atoned or apologized for. This is not playing victim game. You can't seriously think that because the occupation happened 60 years ago it can be forgotten and brushed off.
If in my country a singer would wear a shirt with Nazi symbols, especially with swastika he/she could say goodbye to whatever career they had.
liime_arix 10th-May-2012 10:23 am (UTC)
Leaving this from the allkpop article: The pattern on Hyeri’s shirt resembles the ‘Rising Sun’ Imperial Japanese war flag (not to be confused with the official flag of Japan). It was “heavily used during the colonization of East Asia in the first-half of the 20th century, it is seen offensive to countries that were under control of Japan at that time, especially because of the war crimes that were committed.“ The ‘Rising Sun’ flag is one that is considered extremely taboo in both China & Korea as it is the flag that symbolizes the painful memories of the past.

http://www.allkpop.com/2012/05/girls-day-member-hyeri-apologizes-for-her-controversial-t-shirt
benihime99 10th-May-2012 10:24 am (UTC)
I can understand why some people find that hurtful but bashing that poor girl ain't the solution either

Moreover, that title is misleading

Edited at 2012-05-10 10:25 am (UTC)
moob 10th-May-2012 10:42 am (UTC)
now deliver the killing blow to the struggling nugu!!
kiminikaeru 10th-May-2012 10:58 am (UTC)
i feel sorry for her tbh

also all the weeaboos in here who are like "get our of our beloved nippoN!!!11" need to take several seats tyvm
kazeyumi 10th-May-2012 11:07 am (UTC)
rather than bashing the girl, i'd prefer bashing whoever decided to make that t-shirt. whether they're Korean or Japanese (or whatever they are..), they obviously did not do their homework! .__.
artsxcouture 10th-May-2012 09:12 pm (UTC)
THIS
Page 1 of 3
<<[1] [2] [3] >>
This page was loaded May 20th 2013, 9:27 am GMT.