Arama They Didn't

12:52 pm - 02/09/2013

TV drama captures public angst at 'Made in Japan' decline

MIJ


A Japanese electronics firm near bankruptcy, a ruthless Chinese rival and a laid-off engineer feature in a popular TV drama that is hitting a public nerve in a nation fretting over the decline of a once-admired manufacturing model.

A weaker yen due to Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s expansionary economic policies has lightened some of the gloom for exporters, but NHK public TV’s “Made in Japan” serial reflects a deep angst about an ailing manufacturing sector that was once key to Japan’s success and a source of national pride.

The 3-part drama, which ends on Saturday, covers a secret “restructuring” team’s race against a 3-month deadline to come up with a survival plan for “Takumi Electric” - the name means “artisan” in Japanese - before the bank pulls the plug.

Standing in their way are a Japanese engineer who goes to work in China after being laid off when his lithium-ion battery project was frozen - possibly taking proprietary technology with him - a clueless corporate president given his job by his founder father and a reporter desperate for a scoop.

All of which resonates for many Japanese as they watch once iconic electronics firms - Sony, Panasonic and Sharp come to mind - lose global share to South Korean and Chinese rivals, and wonder what will replace lost manufacturing jobs and drive future economic growth.

“During the period of rapid economic growth after World War II and even after the bursting of the (1980s) asset bubble, manufacturing ... was a source of economic strength,” said Hisao Inoue, a freelance journalist who advised NHK on its script.

“‘Monozukuri’ (‘the making of things’) was a source of pride for Japan,” he told Reuters. “But that has changed and Japan has lost self-confidence.”




The show has won more than respectable Saturday evening ratings of over 10%, and created a buzz among business executives and bankers, with some wondering if it cuts too close to the bone with its portrayal of a firm - however fictional - on the edge.

“The performance is a bit melodramatic, but in a sense, it reflects reality,” said one Japanese banker.

The program’s chief producer Ren Takahashi said the story turned out more realistic than imagined when NHK began work on it two years ago. “The economy was bad then, but we didn’t think the electronics industry would be in such trouble,” he told Reuters, adding “Takumi” was a composite of companies symbolizing Japan rather than being based on one firm.

“There’s no easy solution to the problems of ‘Made in Japan’ ... but we want to end it in a way that gives hope.”

The day before last week’s second episode, government data showed employment in Japan’s manufacturing sector dropped below 10 million for the first time in half a century.

“Japanese have great anxiety about the huge shift in power in East Asia to China on both the security and economic level,” said Jeffrey Kingston, director of Asian Studies at Temple University’s Japan campus. “The (TV) drama is a window into Japan’s collective anxiety about its apparent economic decline.”

Behind the melodrama, the story raises a deeper question: just what is Japan’s famed “monozukuri” ethos and can it survive global competition and world-wide supply chains?

“Monozukuri” is a complex concept that implies craftsmanship and superb quality but with an undertone of rote learning of skills through repetition - a talent key during the era of mass manufacturing but one critics say is not conducive to the innovation Japan needs now.

“It’s been drilled into people for years and years that this is what got Japan back after World War Two,” said Philip Brasor, a media critic who often writes about Japanese society through the prism of TV.

“Inevitably, it all changed. But they still think they can recapture that.”





japantoday

2coco 9th-Feb-2013 11:41 pm (UTC)

not surprising they're losing to S. Korea....pfffttt
glimmeringneon 10th-Feb-2013 06:20 am (UTC)
LOL what's that supported to mean? South Korea is an Asian economic powerhouse, and I would say that it could possibly overtake Japan in terms of quality of life and income per capita.

But that doesn't mean South Korea can overtake Japan as a top Asian powerhouse that easily (its still possible though), there are numerous factors you have to include. For instance, regional and global political influence and military strength is the other key factors. In that aspect Japan is still miles ahead of South Korea.

Japanese economy is declining but it will remain an influential nation. You can't erase the legacies of the rapid modernization of Japan in the early 20th century (the fastest modernization of any Asian country), the Russian defeat by the Japanese in Siberia or the rapid Japanese Imperial expansion of WWII.

Japan is declining but I wouldn't shut down Japan that easily. Do you know the only reason why Japan is not an Asian military powerhouse? Because the Japanese constitution restricts them from making a military force, they can only maintain a defensive force. Don't underestimate the Japanese.

Edited at 2013-02-10 06:22 am (UTC)
crystalluvshun 23rd-Mar-2013 12:51 am (UTC)
I know this is very late, but I just want to get this off my chest.

The article really was only referring to the electronics industry on the world market...if we look at the other major industries like car manufacturing and cosmetics, Japanese car companies like Toyota, Mitsubishi and Mazda, and cosmetic company Shiseido, are still miles ahead of their S.Korean counterparts in the world market. Toyota is still the largest Asian car manufacturer in the world, both in terms of production & sales revenue. And Mazda cars are rapidly becoming very popular overseas.
While Shiseido is probably the largest & most renown Asian cosmetics company in the world.

When we look at Japan's sales growth on the world market, we cannot just look at the electronics department, there are other major industries to consider too like the cars and cosmetics market.
Japan may be losing a lot of shares & profits in the electronics department to their Chinese & S.Korean counterparts, but in other major industries, Japanese companies are still wayyyy ahead in the world markets.

And not to mention Japan is the third largest economy in the world...while S.Korea is still only #15 in the rank.

And glimmeringneon is right, Japan is still a very strong powerhouse that cannot easily be overtaken, they are still a long way ahead of S.Korea in terms of economic growth, global political influence and military influence.
miamaimi 10th-Feb-2013 12:41 am (UTC)
what capitalism gives capitalism takes i guess/ socialist wannabe

but it's not just japan. Old centers of power are having trouble around the world, and the power relationships are shifting. Idk if it's just a problem of monozukuri
arashic5 10th-Feb-2013 12:24 pm (UTC)
True, it's all about apple and Samsung nowadays, but my family is pretty old school, and would still buy made in Japan electronics, we have faith in their technology more
spitfire_bijoux 10th-Feb-2013 12:58 pm (UTC)
Made in Japan products are still better quality though (compared to those made in China and SK, seriously). Just expensive and quite boring. But nobody cares about quality and stability anymore. Everyone wants their stuff fast, flashy, cheap and disposable.

Should Japan sacrifice their trademark workmanship to give the market their quick fix? The Japanese do have a thing for overdesigning and going overboard with making something good as opposed to just good enough (note their packaging on almost everything) and that's not necessarily a good thing too. In this day and age, one must be mindful of resources including time and design. If it's good enough, ship. Not everything has to be perfect.

Edited at 2013-02-10 01:01 pm (UTC)
delicious_pocky 10th-Feb-2013 08:41 pm (UTC)
i don't think they're higher quality than what south korea is currently producing. samsung and lg>>>any japanese company
crystalluvshun 10th-Feb-2013 09:49 pm (UTC)
I disagree.

Panasonic, Sharp, NEC >>>>> any S.Korean company >>>>> any Chinese company

and this is based on my own personal experience, I've used Samsung & LG products before, and did not find them any better than the Panasonic, Sharp and NEC products I've used, I still found the Japanese companies products better overall...however I do find the quality of Sony's products have been declining...at least from my personal experience. Although many people say that Sony's 'Xperia' smartphones are great, just as good as Samsung's 'Galaxy' phones, while some others say the Xperia phones are even better.



Edited at 2013-02-10 10:02 pm (UTC)
stole_away 11th-Feb-2013 02:48 am (UTC)
Currently using Samsung & LG stuffs , they suck srsly.
delicious_pocky 11th-Feb-2013 04:10 am (UTC)
they do but japanese brands sucks even harder currently tbh.
crystalluvshun 11th-Feb-2013 05:18 am (UTC)
everyone has different experiences I suppose...from my personal experience, Japanese brands are still better in quality.
spitfire_bijoux 12th-Feb-2013 02:34 pm (UTC)
Samsung and LG phones are plastic though. It's like they're really not intended to last long since they'll phase them out in a few months anyway. Not so with Japanese phones. Even Japanese TV screen technology is superior, albeit much more expensive. But no1really currs about that so the Japanese should rethink where they invest their quality.

Why do you think no other country even challenges Canon and Nikon when it comes to the Photography market? Because photography gear require true craftsmanship, and the gear is meant to last. You can't scrimp on quality or it will really show.
delicious_pocky 12th-Feb-2013 07:52 pm (UTC)
you make some good points. but yeah, i think we can both agree the fact they're higher quality is meaningless if they can't market it properly and are losing market share crazy fast, even in japan.
crystalluvshun 23rd-Mar-2013 12:56 am (UTC)
let's keep in mind that this article seems to only be referring to electronics companies specifically.

If we look at the international cars and cosmetics markets, Japanese companies like Toyota, Mazda and Shiseido, are still wayyyyyy ahead of their Chinese & S.Korean counterparts.
delicious_pocky 23rd-Mar-2013 12:58 am (UTC)
except toyota and mazda aren't that ways ahead of hyundai AT ALL
crystalluvshun 23rd-Mar-2013 01:00 am (UTC)
no, it's true, Toyota is still by far the largest Asian car manufacturer in the world in terms of production value and sales revenue, way ahead of Hyundai. And Mazda cars are rapidly becoming very popular overseas.

Edited at 2013-03-23 01:01 am (UTC)
delicious_pocky 23rd-Mar-2013 01:01 am (UTC)
they're still leader but they're losing market share while hyundai and kia are gaining it. so yeah, not exactly the best example of how japan's thriving.
crystalluvshun 23rd-Mar-2013 01:09 am (UTC)
but Hyundai and Kia are still a long way behind them in the world market, that it makes it rather difficult for them to catch up to the Japanese manufacturers any time soon.

Also, Toyota's shares and sales have actually risen in the last year compared to the previous year. And Mazda's sales and shares are increasing by the year. So they are not really "losing" shares exactly, they have actually been gaining sales and shares.

Edited at 2013-03-23 01:33 am (UTC)
asweetsymphony 10th-Feb-2013 10:35 pm (UTC)
Japan can gain some comfort in the fact that the made in Japan moniker or any products associated with it is thought of as HIGH QUALITY and is respected. On the other hand, made in China makes people think of sweat shops, cheap materials and low in quality. It's also weird that despite the fact that Samsung is popular, not a lot of people know that it's a Korean company, at least where I live. They usually associate the company with Japan too. I don't know if that's just ignorance or marketing strategy but Samsung needs to do something with that.
crystalluvshun 11th-Feb-2013 02:30 am (UTC)
yeah that's true, although it may be true that Japanese companies are slowly losing ground to other Asian rivals in the world market, Japanese products are still widely considered to be of superior or best quality, and many still are happily inclined to buy products made in Japan knowing that they are buying high quality products.

Whereas most people when they hear 'made in China', they still have this broad impression of cheap/poor quality, mass produced products. Many people often feel they have no choice but to buy inferior quality made in China products simply because China manufactures roughly 70% of all products imported around the world. So often it's quite difficult to avoid made in China products, they're literally everywhere around the world.

Edited at 2013-02-11 02:33 am (UTC)
delicious_pocky 11th-Feb-2013 04:15 am (UTC)
"although it may be true that Japanese companies are slowly losing ground to other Asian rivals in the world market, Japanese products are still widely considered to be of superior or best quality, and many still are happily inclined to buy products made in Japan knowing that they are buying high quality products."

not in brazil. nothing to do with pricing but panasonic/sony -- which were huge in the 90s -- are almost nowhere to be seen and everything samsung sells like crazy. and i'm pretty sure it's the same in the US too considering i live there part time. samsung and apple = 90% of what people are buying right now and consider high-quality, japan isn't "slowly" losing ground, they're losing ground FAST.
crystalluvshun 11th-Feb-2013 04:44 am (UTC)
I think marketing plays a big part, even now I feel that Japanese companies are still a bit too reserved, whereas Korean companies know how to market their products to the wider market.

For example, Samsung makes virtually everything from phones to electronics to household goods. Panasonic makes the same range of products, however, they don't market their products to a wider platform, I mean, a lot of their white goods like rice cookers, fridges, washing machines etc, and their phones too, are mainly concentrated in Japan and probably in other parts of Asia, rarely do you see Panasonic white goods and phones anywhere else in the world, even when you do, there's not much. Whereas Samsung are vigorously making all their products available worldwide.
White goods like fridges and washing machines generate alot of sales and profits, so do mobile phones, but alot of Japanese companies like Panasonic just don't make all their products as widely available as the Korean companies are.

So for Japanese companies to lose ground against other Asian rivals is partially because Japanese companies are still a bit too reserved when it comes to global marketing, and are becoming less competitive. I know alot of Japanese companies including Panasonic, just don't make all their products as widely available worldwide as some of their other Asian counterparts.
So it's not so much that people are not buying their products, it's more to do with the fact that Japanese companies don't make some of their products as widely available. I know here in Australia, I hardly see Panasonic white goods and phones, or any of Sharp or NEC products, because with the latter 2 companies, they've pretty much given up making products for the world market, or are mainly concentrating on their home market & some parts of Asia only. While Panasonic only choose to make certain products available on the world market.
And here, Fujitsu only releases their air conditioners, whereas in Japan, you can find a wide range of Fujitsu products.

A few years ago, Panasonic also expressed interest in returning to the world market for mobile phones, but then they changed their minds later on saying that the global mobile phone market has become too competitive. So instead of giving it a go and releasing their phones in the world market, bringing their phones to the attention of worldwide consumers, Panasonic chose to give up & not make phones for the world market at all. Panasonic phones used to be so big internationally, but now they've just given up making phones for the world market altogether.

But interest in Japanese companies are still at large, many people still would like to use products made by Japanese companies, but often it's hard to find outside of Japan. For example, I love japanese phones, but I cannot buy them anywhere outside Japan, so I always have to buy online & ship directly from Japan. My mum is a big fan of Panasonic products and want to use their washing machines and fridges, but you cannot find them here in Australia (and probably in most parts of the world too)...while Samsung and LG white goods are virtually everywhere.
Like me, there are many people who live overseas who are interested in Japanese phones, but they're just not available in the world market, so people like me always have to order these japanese phones online and ship from Japan directly.
Sony is the only Japanese company that is actively releasing their phones in the global market.

If Japanese companies like Sony, Panasonic and Sharp had marketed ALL their products vigorously in the world market like Samsung and LG are, then I believe they would have been better off now, they would not lose as much profits as they have...they could've even GAINED more profits.
But they are just too reserved tbh and unfortunately have become less competitive when it comes to the world market.

Edited at 2013-02-11 05:47 am (UTC)
delicious_pocky 11th-Feb-2013 07:04 am (UTC)
well, that's japanese companies fault though. marketing is one of the most important aspects, right after quality so if they can't do this properly, it's no wonder they're fucked. and they are fucked: profits are falling year after year and they're losing ground everywhere, including japan (!). their future is not looking pretty and profits are quite terrible compared to years prior. therefore, they're pretty incompetent if they can't market themselves well.

that said, as i already mentioned, sony/panasonic were heavily advertised in brazil in the 90s. nowadays they're nowhere to be seen. pretty much everyone's tv in brazil is LG or samsung when panasonic/sony were kings a few years ago. it's probably the same in the US and in other parts of the world. not to mention the HUGE market share of their cellphones.
crystalluvshun 11th-Feb-2013 10:51 am (UTC)
that's my point, Japanese companies just don't market their products properly to the global market anymore...in the past when Japanese companies ruled, they were very active in the global market...but now there's just so much competition in the global market that it's probably the main reason most Japanese companies have turned their backs on the global market and are now focusing their main attention on their home market and Asia only.
Japanese companies are still too reserved and have become less competitive in the global market, and now with so much competition in the global market, there is still the possibility of them failing & then losing money, and maybe that's why Japanese companies in general, don't want to take that risk. But the fact is, they are losing money and profits anyway...and any improvement in the marketing of their products on a global scale would definitely boost their sales & profits...but it seems most japanese companies in general are just too stubborn to do something about it...they either just don't understand that being virtually absent from the world market is only making their businesses worse, or they do know it but are just intimidated by how competitive the world market has become, it's most likely the latter. Even Panasonic admitted themselves that the global phone market has become too competitive, and that's the reason why they changed their minds about releasing their phones worldwide.

The only Japanese companies that are truly still active in the world market are Sony and Panasonic...sadly all the others have pretty much given up. But even so, both Sony and Panasonic still don't release 'all' their products in the global market...like I pointed out before, Panasonic only releases certain products worldwide, and it's probably the same case with Sony.
But among them both, I think Sony is the one Japanese company that is still the most serious about the global market, which is why they still market alot of their products worldwide, and they still have MANY subsidiaries worldwide. Sony is not just a consumer goods company, it's a conglomerate, which means it's a company that has corporations in numerous completely different business areas. In the US, Sony also owns the 'Sony Pictures Entertainment' film & TV production company, and many other corporations around the world, and let's not forget Sony's own music label that has firms in both Japan and the US, it became the world's largest music publisher in 2012 when they also acquired EMI music.

But I agree that in the end, the japanese companies themselves are really to blame for their own dwindling Japanese economy and company profits, for their lousy marketing of their own products, as most of the companies gave up on the global market & only limiting the distribution of their products to mainly the Japanese market & some parts of Asia.
I think the only way Japan can improve on their economic growth on a global scale is for the japanese companies to change their attitudes about the global markets and start distributing their products worldwide again, like they did in past decades when japanese companies had ruled the global markets.


Edited at 2013-02-11 10:59 am (UTC)
delicious_pocky 11th-Feb-2013 04:13 am (UTC)
samsung works extra hard to make sure they're korean though. they associate themselves with k-pop and korean stars ALL THE TIME. even here in brazil, where kpop isn't popular AT ALL, samsung TVs at shops are usually displaying gangnam style, girls generation etc. i mean, people here don't associate samsung with south korea either but that's cause people here ignore the existence of south korea for the most part and can't really tell the difference between all the asian countries.
This page was loaded May 22nd 2013, 5:32 pm GMT.